Starting vs. Buying a Medical Practice: Which Path Is Right for You?

MDconsultants is a predominantly physician network of talented consultants who solve diverse and challenging problems in various specialties across Canada and the United States. Our company is led by 3 physician partners who graduated from the University of Toronto and is supported professionally by a full-time managerial staff. Our current range of capabilities include healthcare & startup consulting, health services delivery, providing professional second opinions, and occupational & organizational health.

For many physicians, owning a medical practice is a significant career milestone. But when it comes to establishing yourself in private practice, the big question remains: Should you start a practice from scratch or buy an existing one? Each option has its benefits and challenges, and the right decision depends on your financial situation, career goals, and risk tolerance.

In this article, we will break down the pros and cons of starting versus buying a medical practice to help you determine the best path for your professional future.

The Pros and Cons of Starting a Medical Practice

Pros of Starting a Medical Practice

1. Full Autonomy and Control

When you start from scratch, you have complete control over the practice’s location, branding, culture, and operations. You can establish workflows, choose staff, and implement policies that align with your vision for patient care.

2. Ability to Build a Strong Brand

Starting fresh allows you to create a brand that reflects your values and specialties. This can be an excellent opportunity for physicians looking to differentiate themselves in a competitive healthcare market.

3. Opportunity to Utilize the Latest Technology

With no existing infrastructure to modify, you can invest in cutting-edge medical technology, electronic health record (EHR) systems, and innovative treatment methods tailored to your specialty.

 

Opportunity to Utilize the Latest Technology

Cons of Starting a Medical Practice

1. High Initial Costs

Setting up a practice from the ground up requires significant financial investment, including office space, medical equipment, software, licensing, marketing, and staffing.

2. Slow Patient Acquisition

Building a patient base takes time. Unlike an existing practice with a steady flow of patients, you will need to develop referral networks, engage in marketing efforts, and establish credibility in the community.

3. Regulatory and Administrative Challenges

Starting from scratch means navigating legal and regulatory hurdles such as obtaining permits, setting up billing systems, and complying with healthcare laws, which can be time-consuming and complex.

 

High Initial Costs

The Pros and Cons of Buying a Medical Practice

Pros of Buying a Medical Practice

1. Established Patient Base

One of the most significant advantages of buying a medical practice is inheriting an existing patient list, providing immediate revenue and reducing the need for extensive marketing efforts.

2. Proven Business Model

An established practice already has functional workflows, trained staff, and operational policies, reducing the learning curve for a new owner.

3. Easier Financing and Faster Revenue Generation

Lenders are often more willing to finance the purchase of an established practice than fund a new one. With existing cash flow, revenue generation starts immediately, reducing financial stress.

 

Easier Financing and Faster Revenue Generation

Cons of Buying a Medical Practice

1. High Initial Purchase Price

While you avoid startup costs, the upfront investment for an established practice can be substantial, depending on location, reputation, and financial performance.

2. Challenges in Transitioning Patients and Staff

Patients and staff may be accustomed to the previous doctor’s management style and treatment approach. Adapting to a new owner’s methods may take time and effort.

3. Potential Hidden Liabilities

An existing practice may come with unresolved legal issues, outdated equipment, or operational inefficiencies. Conducting thorough due diligence before purchase is crucial to avoid unexpected financial burdens.

Making the Right Decision: Key Considerations

Before deciding between starting or buying a practice, ask yourself these questions:

  • What is my financial position? If you have access to capital and can afford a longer ramp-up period, starting a practice may be viable. If you need immediate income, buying an established practice could be the better option.
  • How much risk am I willing to take? Starting a practice involves greater financial and operational risks, while buying offers more stability.
  • Do I have the time and patience to build a practice from scratch? If you prefer a well-established structure with existing patients, buying might be a smarter choice.
  • Am I comfortable inheriting someone else’s business model? If you value independence and control over your practice’s setup, starting fresh is the way to go.

Conclusion

Deciding between starting or buying a medical practice is a significant career move that requires careful evaluation. Both options have their advantages and challenges, and the best choice depends on your financial resources, career goals, and risk appetite. If you’re looking for guidance on acquiring or setting up a medical practice, seeking professional consulting services can help streamline the process and ensure a successful transition.

Need Help Deciding? Contact MD Consultants Today!

If you’re considering starting or buying a medical practice, expert guidance can make all the difference. MD Consultants offers professional consulting services to help physicians navigate the complexities of practice ownership. Visit our website today to explore how we can support your journey toward a successful medical practice!

Related Reading: Pros and Cons of Buying a Medical Practice